WATTANAPAT HOSPITAL TRANG PUBLIC COMPANY LIMITEDSET: WPH🇹🇭 TH

Internal Control · 2024

Internal Control — Board Opinion

Introduction

The company recognizes the importance of internal control and internal audit systems as fundamental to successful business operations, as well as stable and sustainable growth. Therefore, the company has established effective and efficient internal control and internal audit systems, taking into account appropriateness and adequacy in accordance with the nature, size of the business, and the environment. This ensures that all departments within the organization operate in compliance with relevant rules, regulations, and policies. The company also focuses on accurate, complete, reliable, and up-to-date reporting, and supports operational efficiency and effectiveness.


In addition, the company has an independent internal audit function that reports directly to the Audit Committee. This function assists the Audit Committee and the Board of Directors in ensuring that the main operating processes, including key activities of the Company, are carried out effectively, efficiently, and with appropriate and sufficient control measures.


The company has an Audit Committee responsible for overseeing and reviewing the company's internal control and internal audit systems to ensure their adequacy and effectiveness. The Audit Committee also ensures that the company's operations comply with the Securities and Exchange Act, the Stock Exchange of Thailand's regulations, and other laws relevant to the company's business. The Audit Committee holds meetings at least quarterly to consider and ensure the accuracy, transparency, and completeness of financial reporting. The Audit Committee also prioritizes the review of connected transactions or transactions that may involve conflicts of interest to ensure compliance with the laws and regulations of the Securities and Exchange Commission. The company's auditors attend these meetings to provide observations from their audits of the company.


To ensure the effectiveness of the company's internal control system, the company has appointed Aim to prosperity Co.,Ltd. to audit the company's internal control system from 2016 to the present. This is done in coordination with the company's internal audit department, with reports submitted directly to the Audit Committee on an ongoing basis. The company has continuously rectified and improved deficiencies found from internal audits based on the recommendations of the internal auditors.

Summary of the Board's Opinion on Internal Control

At the Board of Directors' Meeting No. 1/2025 held on February 21, 2025, which was attended by all three audit committee members, the Board of Directors considered the assessment form for the adequacy of the company's internal control system in accordance with the regulations of the Securities and Exchange Commission. This assessment covered the COSO (The Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission) Internal Control Framework, and the Board reviewed supporting documents for the assessment.


The Board of Directors is of the opinion that the internal control system of the company and its subsidiaries is adequate and appropriate for the size and nature of the company's business. The company has allocated sufficient personnel to effectively operate under such a system, resulting in business operations that adhere to the principles of good corporate governance, transparency, and accountability.


In addition, the company has implemented continuous monitoring and supervision of the operations of the company and its subsidiaries to ensure the prevention of unauthorized or improper use of the company's and its subsidiaries' assets. Furthermore, there is an adequate control system in place to oversee transactions with individuals who may have conflicts of interest or related parties to ensure compliance with relevant standards and regulations.

Adequacy & Appropriateness of the Internal Control System

Internal Control Framework Used

FrameworkDetail
The Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission (COSO)


Internal Control Policy of the Company


The company is committed to developing and operating its internal control and internal audit systems to the highest level of effectiveness. The company has adopted the internal control principles of The Committee of Sponsoring Organizations of the Treadway Commission (COSO), an internationally recognized standard, as the main guideline for overseeing the company's internal control system. In addition, the company has adopted a Risk-Based Audit approach to audit and evaluate the internal control system to ensure that the company's operations are efficient, transparent, and in accordance with established standards.


Assessment of the adequacy of the internal control system


At the Board of Directors' Meeting No. 1/2025 held on February 21, 2025, which was attended by all 3 Audit Committee members, the Board of Directors considered and assessed the adequacy of the internal control system of the company and its subsidiaries in accordance with the COSO framework, which defines 5 main components of the internal control system, as follows:

1. Control Environment

2. Risk Assessment

3. Control Activities

4. Information & Communication

5. Monitoring Activities


The Board of Directors has reviewed the documents and supporting evidence, including the internal audit reports of the company and its subsidiaries. The Board is of the opinion that the internal control system of the company and its subsidiaries is adequate and appropriate to the size and nature of the company's business.


The company has recruited qualified personnel to effectively implement the internal control system, resulting in the company's business operations being conducted in accordance with good corporate governance principles, transparency, and accountability.


In addition, the company has established a system to monitor and supervise the operations of the company and its subsidiaries to ensure that the assets of the company and its subsidiaries are protected from unauthorized use or misappropriation. The company also has an adequate control system to oversee transactions with persons who may have conflicts of interest or related parties in strict compliance with relevant laws and regulations.

Internal Control Deficiencies

Introduction

The Company has appointed Aim to prosperity Co.,Ltd. an independent internal audit (Outsource) firm, in conjunction with the company's Internal Audit Department, to audit and monitor the key management systems, including Corporate governance and Environment, Accounting and Finance, Computer and Information Systems, Infrastructure and Safety, Human Resources Management, Procurement Process, Marketing, Nursing, Medical Support, Quality Center, and other support functions.


The company has received recommendations to improve and develop more effective internal control guidelines, focusing on enhancing the checks and balances process in all systems. This will help ensure that the company's operations are standardized and aligned with good corporate governance principles. The company's Internal audit department has continuously monitored the remediation of deficiencies in accordance with the guidelines or recommendations received to enhance the effectiveness of the internal control system and reflect the company's commitment to developing and maintaining the highest standards of internal management systems. The company has resolved all identified deficiencies.

Number of Deficiencies

MetricCurrent YearPrevious YearTwo Years Ago
Total number of internal control system deficiencies (cases)216

Deficiency Details

Period TypeStart Period (YYYY-MM)End Period (YYYY-MM)DetailProgress StatusCorrective Action
month/year Range2024-012024-12
Incomplete inspection of the readiness of tools and equipment according to the established procedures.
Incident no longer subject to action

The supervisor closely monitors the performance of subordinates by randomly inspecting the work of staff at least once a week and records the inspection results as evidence.

Audit Committee & Auditor Observations

Audit Committee's Opinion Differs from the Board's

No

Auditor Has Observations on Internal Control

No

Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit

Head of Internal Audit

3160

Audit Committee's Opinion on the Head of Internal Audit

From 2016 to the present, the Company has appointed Aim to prosperity Co.,Ltd., represented by Mr.Paisan Puratjaroenchai , Managing Director, to act as the head of internal audit. The qualifications of the head of internal audit can be found in Appendix3 . The Audit Committee has considered the qualifications of Aim to prosperity Co.,Ltd., and Mr.Paisan Puratjaroenchai and deems them to be sufficiently qualified for such duties due to their independence and experience in internal audit. The company has established an internal audit department to coordinate with the outsourced internal auditor, to audit and monitor the improvement of deficiencies found from the internal audit, and to report the results of operations to the Audit Committee on a regular basis. The qualifications of the internal audit department personnel are detailed in Appendix 3.


The consideration and approval of the appointment, removal, or transfer of the head of internal audit of the company must be approved or consented to by the Audit Committee.


In addition, the company has assigned Ms. Thipratt Khaiman, company Secretary, to oversee compliance with the rules and regulations of the authorities governing the company's business operations. The qualifications of Ms. Thipratt Khaiman can be found in Appendix 3.

Appointment, Discharge & Transfer of the Head of Internal Audit

Requires Audit Committee Approval

Yes

Description

The consideration and approval of appointments, removals, and transfers of the Head of Internal Audit of the Company must be approved (or acknowledged) by the Audit Committee.


Related Party Transactions

Introduction

Intercompany transactions that occurred during the years ended December 31, 2022 and December 31, 2023, between the Company and individuals/juristic persons that may have conflicts of interest are summarized below.

Has Related Party Transactions

Yes

Counterparties & Transactions

Monetary Unit

1000000

Counterparties with Potential Conflicts

NamePerson / Juristic PersonType of BusinessNature of RelationshipAs of Date (YYYY-MM-DD)
Amara LeelawatPerson

Is the mother of a major shareholder, Vice Chairman, and Chief Executive Officer of the Company.

2024-12-31T00:00
Dr. Vitaya LeelawatPerson

Is the father of a major shareholder and Honorary Advisor.

2024-12-31T00:00
Chollada SuwanmongkolPerson

Company director

2024-12-31T00:00
Miss Namneung LeelawatPerson

Are several of the major shareholders


2024-12-31T00:00
Mom-Cuisine Co., Ltd.Juristic PersonRestaurant Business

Daughter of the company director (Ms. Jariya Leelawat)


2024-12-31T00:00
Dental Art Lab Co., Ltd.Juristic PersonProduction of materials used in making dentures

There is a director who sits on the board of the company, Mr. Pornlert Boonsantisuk


2024-12-31T00:00
Board of Directors and ManagementPerson

Board of Directors and Executives


2024-12-31T00:00

Transactions by Counterparty

Transactions
7.2 · Necessity: To lead the Board of Directors and provide business advice · Description: The company has appointed Ms. Amara Leelawat, a highly knowledgeable and experienced individual, as the Chief Executive Officer and Chairperson of the Executive Board to lead the board and provide business guidance since 2017 until the present. · Nature of transaction: The company paid remuneration to the executive who holds the position of President and Chief Executive Officer. · Audit committee opinion: The aforementioned items are necessary and beneficial for business operations.
0.6 · Necessity: To provide recommendations on policy formulation and strategic operational guidelines · Description: The company has appointed Dr. Vittaya Leelawat as the Honorary Chief Advisor. · Nature of transaction: Honorary Advisor Fee · Audit committee opinion: As Dr. Vitaya Leelawat passed away on January 20, 2023, the aforementioned items will no longer be available.
0.46 · Necessity: As a benefit to employees, which is beneficial to the company's business · Description: The company rents an apartment as a benefit and convenience for employees working late-night shifts and those from other provinces. The rental fee is 38,000 THB per month for a period of two years, from January 1, 2024, to December 31, 2025. · Nature of transaction: Employee Apartment Rental Fee · Audit committee opinion: The aforementioned items are deemed necessary and reasonable as employee benefits, which in turn benefit the company's business operations. The rental property is strategically located near a hospital. The Audit Committee will review the terms and conditions of the transaction before the next contract renewal.
14.54 · Necessity: Provision of food and beverages for inpatients and service recipients. · Description: The company has entered into a contract for meal provision services for a period of three years, from June 1, 2023, to May 31, 2026. · Nature of transaction: Service fee for providing meals to inpatients and service recipients. · Audit committee opinion: The aforementioned service is necessary and reasonable to ensure essential support for patient care. · 0.88 · Necessity: Provision of food and beverages for service recipients. · Description: The company rents out space for restaurant services for a period of three years, from June 1, 2023, to May 31, 2026. · Nature of transaction: Revenue from Rental of Space for Restaurant Services · Audit committee opinion: The aforementioned service is necessary and reasonable to ensure essential support for patient care. · 0.03 · Necessity: Provide healthcare check-up and treatment services for employees of Mum-Cuisine Co., Ltd. · Description: The company provides healthcare and medical treatment services to the employees of Mum-Cuisine Co., Ltd. at the same prices as offered to general customers. This arrangement is expected to continue in the future. · Nature of transaction: Revenue from Medical Services Provided to Employees of MUM-Cuisine Co., Ltd. · Audit committee opinion: The items listed are necessary and reasonable, with terms comparable to those offered to general customers.
0.15 · Necessity: Limited to dental clients with essential needs and those seeking dentures. · Description: The company purchases denture materials from Dental Art Lab Co., Ltd. for dental clients who need dentures. Dental Art Lab Co., Ltd. provides dental prosthetic services and specializes in denture fabrication. The products delivered to the company are of high quality, meet customer and dentist requirements, and are offered at competitive market prices. This business transaction is expected to continue in the future. · Nature of transaction: Purchased materials for making dentures from Dental Art Lab Co., Ltd. · Audit committee opinion: The said list is necessary, reasonable, and beneficial to the business operations, as it is a standard business list with general commercial terms.
6.08 · Necessity: To build morale and motivation among staff and management. · Description: The company provides medical expense benefits to enhance the morale and well-being of its directors and employees who receive medical treatment at Wattanapat Trang Hospital as follows: The Annual General Meeting of Shareholders for the year 2024, held on April 24, 2024, approved medical expense benefits for directors and their spouses with a total limit not exceeding 0.50 million baht per year. In the event that the limit is exceeded, but not exceeding twice the entitled amount, a discount of 50% of the medical expenses per time for inpatients and 25% of the medical expenses per time for outpatients will be provided. If the expenses exceed twice the entitled amount, a discount on medical expenses will be considered in accordance with the general discount policy for service recipients. The aforementioned medical expense benefits remain unchanged from the previous year. Furthermore, the Company's Board of Directors' Meeting No. 14/2016, held on December 1, 2016, resolved to grant executives the right to receive a maximum benefit of 0.10 million baht per year. · Nature of transaction: Healthcare benefits for executives and management. · Audit committee opinion: The list is deemed necessary and reasonable to boost the morale of the committee and executives.
0.63 · Necessity: The company purchases gifts for visiting patients to demonstrate care for its customers. · Description: The company leases space for a convenience store to provide convenience for patients, their relatives, and hospital staff. The area is approximately 65.2 square meters, with a rental rate of 230 baht per square meter. The lease agreement is from October 1, 2023, to September 30, 2026, with a rental rate of 15,000 baht per month. · Nature of transaction: Cost of visitor amenities and space rental · Audit committee opinion: The said list is necessary, reasonable, and beneficial to the business operations, as it is a standard business list with general commercial terms.

Policy & Future Trends

Policy, Measures & Approval Process

The company has established procedures for the approval of intercompany transactions in accordance with the Securities and Exchange Act and the regulations, notifications, orders, or requirements of the Securities and Exchange Commission and the Stock Exchange of Thailand. Directors or persons who may have a conflict of interest, have a vested interest, or may have any conflict of interest with the company are not entitled to vote on the approval of such intercompany transactions.

In the event that the law requires intercompany transactions to be approved by the Board of Directors' Meeting, the Company will arrange for the Audit Committee to attend the meeting to consider and provide opinions on the necessity and reasonableness of such transactions, with the following guidelines:

• Transactions with general commercial terms: The Board of Directors has approved in principle that the management may enter into intercompany transactions with general commercial terms if such transactions have commercial terms similar to those that would be entered into with other parties in the same circumstances, with bargaining power that is free from the influence of their status as directors, executives, or connected persons (as the case may be). The company will prepare a report summarizing such transactions for reporting to the Audit Committee and the Board of Directors on a quarterly basis.

• Ordinary course of business transactions and transactions supporting the ordinary course of business without general commercial terms, and other intercompany transactions, such as building rental and financial assistance transactions, such as loans and guarantees. The company has a policy to propose such transactions to the Board of Directors for approval, with the Audit Committee attending the meeting and providing opinions on the reasonableness and necessity of the transactions before entering into such transactions. The company must comply with the Securities and Exchange Act, the regulations, notifications, orders, or requirements of the Stock Exchange of Thailand, including compliance with the requirements on the disclosure of connected transactions and the acquisition or disposal of major assets of the Company or its subsidiaries (if any), and compliance with the accounting standards on the disclosure of information on related parties or related party transactions as prescribed by the Federation of Accounting Professions under the Royal Patronage. The company will disclose intercompany transactions in the notes to the company's financial statements, including Form 56-1 and the Annual Report.

In addition, in the event that the Audit Committee is required to provide an opinion on the appropriateness of such transactions and the Audit Committee does not have the expertise to consider the intercompany transactions that have occurred, the company will arrange for a qualified person, such as an independent auditor or property valuer, to provide an opinion on the intercompany transactions. The opinion of the Audit Committee or the qualified person will be used in conjunction with the decision of the Board of Directors or shareholders, as the case may be, to ensure that such transactions do not result in the transfer or shifting of benefits between the Company or persons who may have a conflict of interest with the Company, but are transactions that the company has considered in the best interests of all shareholders.

Future Trends in Related Party Transactions

Potential future intercompany transactions must be reviewed by the Audit Committee and the Board of Directors, with the Audit Committee present, to consider and provide opinions on the necessity and reasonableness of such transactions. They will also review the prices and terms of the transactions to ensure they are comparable to those of unrelated parties. The directors must comply with all established regulations and will not be entitled to vote to approve any transaction in which they or any person with a potential conflict of interest have any other dealings with the company.

For the future trend of intercompany transactions, they will still exist in the normal course of the company's business, including employee dormitory rentals, food service contracts and kitchen space rentals, medical services, and the purchase of materials for making dentures.

However, the company will conduct the aforementioned transactions with transparency and in accordance with the company's policy on intercompany transactions, and in strict compliance with the regulations of the SEC, the Stock Exchange of Thailand, and other relevant agencies.

Contents